Home Is Where The Wind Blows

Dennis McCarthy: Why are you, fellow etherist, not as stupid as we are?  (16-Apr-2003)

Ilja Schmelzer wrote in message news:...
> "Titan Point" writes:
> > On Tue, 15 Apr 2003 07:45:45 -0700, greywolf42 wrote:

> > > Are you so afraid that an aetherist COULD come up with a theoretical
> > > explanation?
>
> > No I'm not afraid of reality. I am afraid of waiting a lifetime waiting
> > for you to produce an explanation of this result using a non-GR theory.
>
> Of course, waiting for greywolf42 to produce such an explanation based
> on greywolf42's pet theory may be waste of time.
>
> But once the question is if "an aetherist COULD come up", resp. about
> "_a_ non-GR theory", no problem: The non-GR theory proposed in
> gr-qc/0205035 gives the Einstein equations of GR in some limit.
> This should be sufficient to explain such results, not?

   What on Earth is the purpose of your first sentence above?
Are you trying to show that since you are willing to insult other
etherists that this may help to legitimize you in some way? Do you
feel that since relativists are so quick to launch into personal and
degrading attacks, so eager to brand and to destroy character, that
these tactics may help you move within their penumbra of self-imposed
authority?
   You are the only etherist of whom I am aware (and I know dozens
personally), who is so eager to help throw rocks at the heretics, so
willing to defend the despicable personal attacks and inexcusable
tactics of relativists.
   So I guess what I'm trying to ask: Do you try to belittle other
etherists because you endeavor to ingratiate yourself with relativists
or do you do it just because you are obnoxious?

--Dennis McCarthy

   Index   Original post and context: 68aae149.0304151714.5033046c@posting.google.com