>>> > All geodesics do obey Fermat's principle of Least Time. That is the >>> > reason why Snell's law exists. Any object moves from one point in >>> > space to another through the path with the least accumulated amount of >>> > time. > > Before making a general statement, why not see if it is true for > a few simple cases. Here's a case: you throw a ball straight up > into the air, and it comes back to you. What is the height h as > a function of time t? Does the path minimize the total time? > > Well, if we treat the acceleration of gravity as approximately > constant, call it g, then the time required for the ball to > return to its starting place is > > T = 2 v0/g > > where v0 is the initial upwards speed. > > If v0 = 25 meters/second, g = 10 meters/second^2, then T = 5 seconds. > Is that the smallest possible time? Obviously not. Suppose that the > ball travels straight up at speed 25 meters/second for 1 second, turns > around, and comes back down at speed 25 meters/second for 1 second. > Then the whole trip would only be 2 seconds. What if the ball travels > at 25 meters per second for 1 second, and then turns around and travels > 50 meters per second for 1/2 second. Then the trip would only be 1.5 > seconds. 5 seconds is *not* the smallest possible time. You have two different metrics. One involves with (g = 10m/sec^2), and the other one has (g = 25m/sec^2). Each one obeys the principle of Least Time. You need to study the calculus of Variations. Learn how the geodesic equations are derived from this very Langrangian method. |
|
Fumble Index | Original post & context: 1159661032.641458.32200@b28g2000cwb.googlegroups.com |