Home Is Where The Wind Blows

An immortal fumble by Koobee Wublee (Australopithecus Afarensis ...) (1-Oct-2006)

You have two different metrics

>>> > All geodesics do obey Fermat's principle of Least Time.  That is the
>>> > reason why Snell's law exists.  Any object moves from one point in
>>> > space to another through the path with the least accumulated amount of
>>> > time.
> 
> Before making a general statement, why not see if it is true for
> a few simple cases. Here's a case: you throw a ball straight up
> into the air, and it comes back to you. What is the height h as
> a function of time t? Does the path minimize the total time?
>
> Well, if we treat the acceleration of gravity as approximately
> constant, call it g, then the time required for the ball to
> return to its starting place is
>
>      T = 2 v0/g
>
> where v0 is the initial upwards speed.
>
> If v0 = 25 meters/second, g = 10 meters/second^2, then T = 5 seconds.
> Is that the smallest possible time? Obviously not. Suppose that the
> ball travels straight up at speed 25 meters/second for 1 second, turns
> around, and comes back down at speed 25 meters/second for 1 second.
> Then the whole trip would only be 2 seconds. What if the ball travels
> at 25 meters per second for 1 second, and then turns around and travels
> 50 meters per second for 1/2 second. Then the trip would only be 1.5
> seconds. 5 seconds is *not* the smallest possible time.

You have two different metrics.  One involves with (g = 10m/sec^2), and
the other one has (g = 25m/sec^2).  Each one obeys the principle of
Least Time.  You need to study the calculus of Variations.  Learn how
the geodesic equations are derived from this very Langrangian method.
 Fumble Index  Original post & context:
 1159661032.641458.32200@b28g2000cwb.googlegroups.com