PD <TheDraperFamily@gmail.com> wrote in message 816b0970-860b-4d17-a75d-67b434d91326@y21g2000hsf.googlegroups.com > On Sep 8, 3:48 pm, iqgoo...@gmail.com wrote: >> On Sep 8, 3:59 pm, PD <TheDraperFam...@gmail.com> wrote: [reconstructed - as usual] >>>> Back to question: does the nature of mass differ in each case? >> >>>> Hint: A question is technically not an answer. >> >>> Exactly. You didn't answer my question. You asked a question instead. >>> Are you interested in providing an answer? >> >> This thread has only 1 question (the rest are smokes and mirrors): > > I've asked you two questions about your claims in this post: > "What is the testable proposition, do you think?" > "Is a massive electron a figment of the imagination where reality is > nothing but massless mathematical points? " > > You answered neither of these questions and then you asked ME a > question about non-massive electrons. So I asked: > "What's a non-massive electron?" > >> >> "If the world was pure abstraction to begin with, then how did this >> abstract world engender the existence of a material world?" > > So let's see. > So far you've asked a question about your own book and scoffed when no > one is forthcoming with an answer about your own book. I've asked you > three questions about statements you made, and you've not answered any > of them. > > Since you seem to be having some difficulty not slipping around on > your own sh*t, let's see if you can answer some questions directly > pertaining to your one question about your own book: > > 1. What makes you think the world was "pure abstraction to begin > with"? It's kind of foolish to ask a question where the premise is not > obviously correct. > 2. What do you think constitutes the property of being "material"? > That is, in YOUR mind, what distinguishes the material from the > immaterial? I'd like you to be very precise in this answer, because > we'd rely on that definition in much that we'd discuss. > > PD PD, answer the question as it is. If you can't, then simply admit it. |
|
Fumble Index | Original post & context: fcac9f38-527f-4440-85f2-160dbd57e36a@l43g2000hsh.googlegroups.com |