Home Is Where The Wind Blows

Marcel Luttgens: SR IS DEFINITELY WRONG  (16-Mar-2002)

To Paul B. Andersen (paul.b.andersen@hia.no)

In fact, like other SR experts, you forgot how the LT
have been derived.
In particular, time is counted from the instant at
which the origins of the two frames of reference S and S'
coincide. Iow, t=t'=0 when x=x'=0.
If a light pulse or an object starts from the coincident
origins at time t=t'=0, it will be at x=ct or x=Vt according
to S, and at x'=ct' or x'=V't' according to S'.

The classical LT x'=gamma(x-vt) and t'=gamma(t-vx/c^2) can be
written x'=gamma*t(V-v) and t'=gamma*t(1-Vv/c^2), where x=Vt.
Clearly, t' can be negative only if V>c, which is forbidden
by relativity.

   Index   Original post and context: 243a1189.0203160522.280953fb@posting.google.com