Daryl McCullough wrote:
> Thomas says...
>
> >OK, with A=E and B=D we have then
>
> Wait a minute. Are you now in agreement that you
> were wrong about your *original* reason for saying
> that Einstein's derivation is inconsistent? You
> seem to be moving onto a completely different
> argument.
>
> We've discovered algebraic mistakes that you've
> made, and algebraic mistakes that I've made, but
> we have not yet found an algebraic mistake that
> Einstein made.

I have never claimed that Einstein made an algebraic mistake but that
his equations are mathematically inconsistent as he worked from the
equations
    x-ct=0
    x+ct=0
which is inconsistent unless everything is identically zero. If I had
to review a paper containing these equations, I would reject it out of
hand (whether it was written by Einstein or anybody else).