Home Is Where The Wind Blows

An immortal fumble by Jim Greenfield (30-Jul-2003)

The role of democracy and mathematics in science
> > > PS I don't accept that democracy has a place in science. If more
> > > people vote for a position which is wrong, then just more are wrong
> > > than correct. In especially Relativity matters, there is also all that
> > > more vote buying power of the grant, position, lifetimes' programming,
> > > Institutional prestige etc, to grind down an opposing view point.
> > > I also don't expect DHR's to recant anytime soon. Neither is it
> > > likely the Pope will, although many question that a man three days
> > > dead, got up and flew off to heaven.
> > >
> > >Jim G
> >
> > I do, however, feel that you should say a theory is wrong for things
> > actually concluded from it.  That requires the critics of relativity to
> > study it, and many of them on this newsgroup seem remarkably unwilling to
> > do so.
> 
> Most of them brown their underpants when they see an
> equation. A few of the more gifted ones who can grasp
> a square root usually go down when they see an integral.
> But they can be really entertaining :-)
> 
> Dirk Vdm

So you'd be in the maths book which explains in detail how two
negative numbers multiplied, give a positive. Then in the next
chapter, give an equally believable (to fools) explanation of the
square root of a negative number. Use enough of these (imaginary)
numbers and formula, I guess you can "prove" anything (to the
gullible!!)
 Fumble Index  Original post & context:
 3c4afb26.0307292308.142765f2@posting.google.com