Home Is Where The Wind Blows

An immortal fumble by Barry Mingst (greywolf42) (26-May-2003)

And all you need is speed of gravity
heimdall <vze3t7fc@verizon.net> wrote in message
news:b0601654.0305260516.1d8f8ec8@posting.google.com...
> I have seen the progression of the perihelion of Mercury
> described as the effect of the light-speed of gravity, but
> also as the effect of the time dilation and space expansion
> (spacetime curvature) nearer the sun.
>
> Undoubtedly, both spacetime curvature and gravity contribute,
> but which is more important?  Gerber, I think, explained it
> entirely as a function of light-speed, but, I understand, his
> explanation was wrong although his formula was correct.
>
> Is there a good reference to explaining the motion of the
> perihelion, preferably one that introduces just enough mathematics
> to get the job done?
>
> Heimdall

Yes.  An excellent reference for this is Petr Beckmann's "Einstein Plus
Two."  And all you need is speed of gravity.  (By the way, there are NO
errors in Gerber's work.)  Pauli et al dislike Gerber's derivation because
it is not a complete theory of gravity.  Not because there are errors in
Gerber's work.  (At least no errors have ever been published or noted in
what Gerber actually DID.)  GR's results are also the result solely of
finite gravity speed.

greywolf42
ubi dubium ibi libertas
 Fumble Index  Original post & context:
 vd4eur2dcdvk09@corp.supernews.com